PAGE 118

Alaska Airborne Infantry

On p. 118 of GR, Sarah continues her discussion of the time she chose to be present at the deployment ceremony for the Alaska-based Airborne Infantry Brigade over attending yet another luncheon in connection with the 2006 campaign for the Governorship of Alaska. She wrote on p. 117, "I chose the troops, the other guys chose the luncheon."

Now she continues on the same subject, "My opponents and the press had a field day with that one: 'Palin a No-Show at Chamber of Commerce Luncheon Debate.' The guys' campaigns raised such a fuss about it that they wouldn't let Sean [Parnell--lieutenant-governor candidate] participate; he was permitted to give only short opening remarks.

"I couldn’t make the media understand why I had chosen to skip another rubber-chicken campaign stop and instead attend this significant military exercise. I tried to explain: the chamber of commerce would be here next week; our troops would not."

Well, is it true that she did not appear at the luncheon?

Yes …

… the material fact is true enough.

However, in this place we may make a very useful distinction between "material" facts and "formal" motives.

This distinction is so crucial that it can make the difference between noble actions and ignoble ones; between heroism and villainy … in the end it can make the difference between Heaven and Hell.

Material facts are like a blank metal coin. The motivation behind acts is like the image that is stamped on that coin. The images can range anywhere on the moral spectrum from the image of Christ to the image of Satan.

Yes, it is true that she did not show up at this luncheon, but it was to serve a much higher and loftier purpose and goal: To honor our troops!!

Suppose, for example, that a woman kills a man with a firearm. That is a material fact.

But what is the motive?

If it is to rob him of his goods, the act is gravely evil.

But what if it is a case like that of Scarlett O'Hara in the book and movie "Gone with the Wind"??

Scarlett shoots a Yankee deserter who threatens violence to her person and to her home.

Scarlett shoots him dead. The homicide is justifiable, even praiseworthy!

As we confront, then, the Ministers of Mendacity, who are in service to barack obama and to Sarah's enemies in the GOP Establishment, we must wield the mighty Sword of Truth, the Blade of Keen Intellectual Distinctions.

They will try to muddy our minds and confuse our spirits and dismay our hearts in the War for America.

We must meet them and crush them, with minds and hearts that are made up at once of gold and of steel.

GOLD, TO LOVE ALL THAT IS TRUE AND BEAUTIFUL AND GOOD;

STEEL, TO CUT TO PIECES AND RIBBONS FOUL WEBS AND TANGLES OF FALSEHOOD.

And we must make choices like the one that our Sarah made in 2006, placing the REALITY of honoring our troops over the APPEARANCE of showing up at a luncheon.

We must choose, as she did, as she does, to do what is RIGHT …

And damn the outward appearances and the temporary consequences.

"I chose the troops; the other guys chose the luncheon."

Read It For Yourself:

Other Great Sarah Books:

Palin Essentials:

Credits:

All sidebar photos are from Wikimedia. I have tried to post all royalty-free images or to get permission, but in a few cases I could not locate the original source of a photograph or find a way to ask permission.


Contact info: bbrianus@gmail.com.

Other Great Going Rogue Reviews:

Jedediah Bila:

"Palin’s inviting first-person narration that is sometimes whimsical, often confident, and always patriotic...Going Rogue is truly one of those reads in which you put the book down after your eyes graze the final lines and you somehow feel like the writer is someone you’ve known all your life."
John Ziegler:

"I was simply blown away by Going Rogue on almost every level. For many reasons, this is by far the best book and greatest literary achievement by a political figure in my lifetime..."
Brigadier General Anthony J. Tata:
"Her book washes away all doubts that any reader might have had about her readiness to be president. She comes across as exceptionally bright, dedicated, and passionate about public service. Her moral compass is strong, pointing true North in this case. And she has a wicked sense of humor."
Don Surber:
"Conservatives know why Palin is still standing — and standing taller today than those who tried to bring her down. What does not kill you makes you stronger. Thank you, Tina Fey."

Sarah Palin is Coming to Town

Review by Stanley Fish:

When I walked into the Strand Bookstore in Manhattan last week, I headed straight for the bright young thing who wore an “Ask Me” button, and asked her to point me to the section of the store where I might find Sarah Palin’s memoir, “Going Rogue: An American Life.” She looked at me as if I had requested a copy of “Mein Kampf” signed in blood by the author....


A few days later...I had begun reading Palin’s book, and while I wouldn’t count myself a fan in the sense of being a supporter, I found it compelling and very well done....

First, the art. The book has an architectonic structure that is built around a single moment, the moment when Palin receives a call from John McCain inviting her to be the vice-presidential candidate of the Republican party. When we first hear about the call it is as much a surprise to us as it was (at least as reported) to her, because for six pages she has been recounting a wonderful family outing at the Alaska State Fair. When her phone rings, she hopes it might be a call from her son Track, a soldier soon to deploy to Iraq, but “it was Senator John McCain asking if I wanted to help him change history.”

And that’s the last we hear of it for 200 pages. In between we hear a lot about Wasilla, high school, basketball, college, marriage, children, Down syndrome, Alaska politics, the environment, a daughter’s pregnancy. The re-entry of John McCain into the narrative on page 208 introduces Palin’s account of the presidential campaign and its aftermath, especially her decision to resign the governorship before the end of her term....


Paradoxically, the effect of the neatly spaced references to the call is to de-emphasize it as a dramatic moment. It is presented not as a climax, but as an interruption of matters more central to Palin’s abiding concerns — her family, Alaska’s prosperity, energy policy. (She loves to rehearse the kind of wonkish details we associate with Hillary Clinton, whom she admires.)

Indeed, it is a feature of this narrative that events we might have expected to be foregrounded are elided or passed over. Palin introduced herself to the nation with a powerful, electrifying speech accepting McCain’s invitation to join the ticket. It gets half a sentence (“I gave my speech”)....


The only event that receives an extended discussion is her resignation. It is important to her because as an act it reflects on her integrity, and she has to be sure (as she eventually was) that she was doing it for the right reasons.

Resigning was a moral act for which she was responsible. The vice-presidential candidacy just happened to her; her account of it reads like an extended “what-I-did-on-my summer-and fall-vacation” essay.


For many politicians, family life is sandwiched in between long hours in public service. Palin wants us to know that for her it is the reverse. Political success is an accident that says nothing about you. Success as a wife, mother and citizen says everything...

I find the voice undeniably authentic...It is the voice of small-town America, with its folk wisdom, regional pride, common sense, distrust of rhetoric (itself a rhetorical trope), love of country and instinctive (not doctrinal) piety.

It says, here are some of the great things that have happened to me, but they are not what makes my life great and American. (“An American life is an extraordinary life.”) It says, don’t you agree with me that family, freedom and the beauties of nature are what sustain us?


And it also says, vote for me next time. For it is the voice of a politician, of the little girl who thought she could fly, tried it, scraped her knees, dusted herself off and “kept walking.”

In the end, perseverance, the ability to absorb defeat without falling into defeatism, is the key to Palin’s character. It’s what makes her run in both senses of the word and it is no accident that the physical act of running is throughout the book the metaphor for joy and real life. Her handlers in the McCain campaign wouldn’t let her run (a mistake, I think, even at the level of photo-op), no doubt because they feared another opportunity to go “off script,” to “go rogue.”

But run she does (and falls, but so what?), and when it is all over and she has lost the vice presidency and resigned the governorship, she goes on a long run and rehearses in her mind the eventful year she has chronicled. And as she runs, she achieves equilibrium and hope: “We’ve been through amazing days, and really, there wasn’t one thing to complain about. I feel such freedom, such hope, such thankfulness for our country, a place where nothing is hopeless.”

The message is clear. America can’t be stopped. I can’t be stopped. I’ve stumbled and fallen, but I always get up and run again. Her political opponents, especially those who dismissed Ronald Reagan before he was elected, should take note. Wherever you are, you better watch out. Sarah Palin is coming to town.

  © Blogger templates Sunset by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP